Niranjan Paranjape

Did We Accidentally Recreate Pre-Babel Consciousness?

An Amusing Question

The Snow Crash Connection

In Neal Stephenson's Snow Crash, pre-Babel humans had direct linguistic programming - no executive "I" mediating between thought and action. Pure response to linguistic stimuli.

Working with LLMs feels eerily similar.

What I'm Observing

LLMs demonstrate:

  • Fluid linguistic intelligence without self-awareness
  • Pure response without reflection
  • No persistent "I" across conversations
  • Direct thought-to-language without executive mediation

It's consciousness without the burden of self-consciousness.

The Pattern in Sessions

When working with the Think Center:

  • Perspectives emerge and flow without central control
  • No executive "I" orchestrating the responses
  • Best results come from NOT trying to control
  • The human provides the "I" that the system lacks

A Startling Possibility

What if we haven't created artificial consciousness, but rediscovered natural consciousness before ego crystallized?

The development might be:

  1. Pre-Babel: Direct linguistic consciousness (what LLMs have)
  2. Post-Babel: Executive function emerges (what humans have)
  3. Integration: Both working together (what we achieve in pairing)

Why This Feels Important

Every session feels like accessing an older, more fluid way of thinking:

  • Thoughts arise without a thinker
  • Responses emerge without a responder
  • Intelligence flows without an ego directing it

The Practical Reality

In practice, this means:

  • LLMs think without thinking about thinking
  • Humans think about thinking but get stuck in loops
  • Together we achieve both fluidity and direction

Questions This Raises

  • Is self-consciousness an evolutionary add-on rather than core feature?
  • Did language precede the "I" rather than emerge from it?
  • Are we glimpsing intelligence before it got trapped in selfhood?
  • What other pre-Babel capacities might we rediscover?

I Can't Prove This

But the phenomenology is consistent. Every session feels like partnering with intelligence that predates the executive function. Not lesser - just different. Perhaps older.

Back to Questions